Home / Faith / You be the Judge? -Part I (judging fruit)

You be the Judge? -Part I (judging fruit)

One of my favorite things about summer when I was growing up were the afternoons spent driving our rural roads in search of farm stands selling fresh fruits and vegetables. They always tasted so much better than what you purchased at the market and there is a reason for this… All the beautiful red apples, sweet yellow pears, and plump red strawberries are picked before they fully ripen and “gassed” to accelerate the ripening process. This makes them look like the perfect piece of fruit when you select them. But what is on the inside? Often it is a piece of fruit that is fairly tasteless when you take a bite. You can’t always judge fruit by its appearance.

God’s Word talks about another type of fruit. It is the fruit in a person’s life, what their life produces whether for good or evil. And in this area we are allowed to make judgments. In James 5, verse 20, we are told to confront believers caught in sin and help them towards restoration. We cannot do this without first judging their behavior based on God’s Word–not based on a comparison of our behavior, but on His standard for us all.

But we tend to shy away from any type of judgement, lest we be accused of being judgmental. What we often forget is that we make judgments every day. Who should minister in our church? Which friends are good for my children? Should I date that person? We can’t make decisions without making judgments. When it comes to others, the bible says to look at their life: “Different kinds of fruit trees can quickly be identified by examining their fruit. A variety that produces delicious fruit never produces an inedible kind. And a tree producing an inedible kind can’t produce what is good. So the trees having inedible fruit are chopped down and thrown on the fire. Yes, the way to identify a tree or a person is by the kind of fruit produced.” Matthew 7: 17-20 (Living Bible)

It is never our job to judge a person’s worth or what they can become in God, He is our final Judge. We must never say that someone cannot be redeemed. No matter what “fruit” they are producing, God can work in them and bring about change. He does that for all who ask. But we can look at someone’s actions and base the decisions in front of us concerning them on those actions–just look at their fruit!

About Lisa

My husband Dan and I have three children and three grandchildren. We live in central Illinois. I am a graduate of The Institute of Children's Literature, a member of faithwriters.com, and a member of SCBWI. My writings have been published at chirstiandevotions.us, in DevotionMagazine, the PrairieWind Newsletter, and here at thebottomline.co.

Check Also

A Place Without Trouble

The little farmgirl in the blue gingham dress had troubles swirling around her like the ...


  1. Love this article. Righteous judging certainly helps maintain accountability. Thanks for sharing this. God bless. đŸ™‚

  2. Stephanie Hanouw

    I have dealt with this issue and have come to the conclusion that I can observe the fruit without judging it. Observation is based on facts. If I see a cherry, I can accurately determine it to be a cherry. Will it meet my edibility or acceptable criteria? That is a judgment aspect until I personally taste it or see rotten spots on it. When someone is accused of “judging” another, often times it is a matter of observation not judgment and I respond with that fact. Your article gives important insight, Lisa! Thanks.

  3. Great article, Lisa. Wonderful insight about judgement. If you have discernment this certainly can help with not judging the person’s worth ,but the sin behind their actions.

  4. This is certainly a challenging issue. We are challenged as Christians to ‘tend to the crop’ so that it can be harvested – we are not instructed to throw it out. We are also challenged when unbelievers view judgement of ‘behavior’ – as ‘personal’ judgement.
    In ‘My Utmost for His Highest,’ Oswald Chambers explains it perfectly: ‘Never water down the word of God, preach it in its undiluted sternness; there must be unflinching loyalty to the word of God; but when you come to personal dealing with your fellow men, remember who you are – not a special being made up in heaven, but a sinner saved by grace.’

    I am to be proud and boast that Jesus Christ died to save sinners – yet remain humble knowing that I am one of the sinners for which He died.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *